Having recently seen the movie, The Iron Lady, and read the reviews previous to that, I can understand why many left wing reviewers dislike this movie.
It demonstrates, above and beyond all other possible examples, that one man of courage, or in this case a woman, constitutes a majority. The vast majority of so-called conservatives are nothing but imitation socialists of a more moderate persuasion. The irony of Margaret Thatcher's life is that as an individual, she triumphed over a collectivist mentality within her own party but only for a time.
As age advances, it becomes inevitable that the majority of those who prefer mediocrity to perfection or anything close to it, and compromise as opposed to truth or justice, will bring down those individuals who rise above the herd.
Friday, February 10, 2012
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Gratitude
Friday, February 3, 2012
Free Speech the Modern Battlefield
I remember being wakened on the morning of January 23, 2012 by a radio announcer attributing words to Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin in a speech to students at Carleton University. It was stated “she wondered whether fairness and accuracy might be lost in the world of Facebook, Tweets, and instant messaging,” and the justice system must learn to deal with social media such as Twitter and Facebook. These remarks, I thought, must surely misrepresent her views and are probably taken out of context, as I have seen the media do so often with me.
So I decided to wait until I could see the media coverage in more detail. I finally obtained the Globe and Mail article of January 23 which revealed even more startling statements.
The title of the article read “Chief Justice muses about the impact of Twitter, Facebook on Canadian justice,” which caused me to observe on later examination of the articles that judges shouldn’t “muse.”
The premise that immediately leapt out at me was the assertion attributed to the Chief Justice that “the media in general are essential to building trust in the administration of Justice.” Really? I thought the duty of the 5th Estate was to criticize, hold accountable, and question the administration of justice. How much would have had an unjust result if the media viewed its job as building public trust? It was books critical of the justice system which finally reversed the Truscott decision. Too often the public trust built by the media in the justice system gives us a Milgaard case where 25 years too late, an innocent man is released from a false allegation, only by someone who writes and for good cause, undermines trust in the administration of justice when that administration is clearly wrong. But the clarity of the wrong is never clear at the beginning. For 25 years, the system said Truscott, Milgaard, Sophenow, Morin, and many others were guilty, when they really were not. Does the Chief Justice think these injustices only occur in first degree murder cases? Should there always be public trust in the administration of justice? What if the courts are wrong? Why shouldn’t the media point this out? Why should the judiciary be above criticism? I say the media need to criticize the administration of justice.
So why does the Chief Justice require media trust building? Because she is now the authority. Authority always demands protection for itself and it has the means to achieve it.
Chief Justice McLachlin also wondered whether fairness and accuracy might be lost in the world of Facebook, tweets, and instant messaging.
One might equally wonder whether people in conversation are fair and accurate, but should it matter? Where should regulation stop? Don’t we want people to discuss the justice system in their own words, or should they just agree? Should the justice system co-opt and regulate the media of modern discussion: the internet.
As one who is frequently misquoted, misrepresented, and vilified in the media, I would say the media are already unfair and inaccurate. She only has a different view because given her position of power and prestige; the media are always deferential, respectful, and solicitous. The mainstream media and the establishment go hand in hand. The mainstream media have the guile to slant the news to make the establishment look good if they know what’s good for them and they do.
Imagine the attitude of someone who says “Some bloggers will be professionals and academics providing thoughtful commentary and knowledge. Others will fall short of basic journalistic standards.” What a series of fallacies and false assumptions are inherent in these two statements. First, the fallacy of authority, as if academics and professionals are not biased and have no evil intent, but only objectively present analysis. Some do and some don’t. Academia and the professions are rife with political motives, intrigue, and self-serving cliques. I well remember the Milgaard case was seen as so exemplary it was in our evidence text in the late 1960s. Secondly, basic journalistic standards are a problematic assertion. What are they? My experience is that there aren’t any if you are unpopular, and if you are popular or powerful like the Chief Justice of Canada, you just have to mention those words and heads nod in agreement as they do to most of your statements.
Finally, how can “Twitter inform the public accurately or adequately in 140 characters or less the real gist of a complex constitutional decision?” Here to me we see a series of questionable assumptions. Firstly, what Supreme Court of Canada decision lately even hopes to inform the public, being usually in 140 paragraphs or pages, not characters? The various paragraphs, complex language, and conflicting dissents frequently leave lawyers in doubt. Older decisions of the court 60 years or more ago, before the era of cut and paste, were short, simple, and comprehensible, so where do long decisions lead us? To even longer commentary and confusion as well as an intellectually sterile, incomprehensible, technical language, which is better suited to occult societies than public understanding. The use of terms of art so typical of Supreme Court writing is specifically designed to exclude the public and build the professional monopoly of the elite. If the Supreme Court wants “real gist” (which seldom can be found) to be publicly understood, maybe they should write short, comprehensible, simple, and principled judgements rather than criticize much less ban Twitter.
It’s one thing for judges to decide to regulate their own behaviour, perhaps not musing in public, but it’s another for them to tell the public how they can communicate their observations and opinions about the justice system.
The regulation of online publicity is really impossible if you allow one person to communicate to another, because they will do so about the courts and justice as well. The hardest thing is to lose control of the messages, especially about yourself, as I have come to know from the selective, one-sided, seemingly uncorrectable Wikipedia biography of me. But any public figure knows the alternative is worse. To control what others say about you by force of law is impossible except for blatant false statements of fact, which seldom go unpunished. For the rest – fair comment – which usually isn’t fair, we have to grin and bear it. If we do, why should the courts be any better protected? Or does the Chief Justice really prefer an elite of professionals and academics to decide what we think?
So I decided to wait until I could see the media coverage in more detail. I finally obtained the Globe and Mail article of January 23 which revealed even more startling statements.
The title of the article read “Chief Justice muses about the impact of Twitter, Facebook on Canadian justice,” which caused me to observe on later examination of the articles that judges shouldn’t “muse.”
The premise that immediately leapt out at me was the assertion attributed to the Chief Justice that “the media in general are essential to building trust in the administration of Justice.” Really? I thought the duty of the 5th Estate was to criticize, hold accountable, and question the administration of justice. How much would have had an unjust result if the media viewed its job as building public trust? It was books critical of the justice system which finally reversed the Truscott decision. Too often the public trust built by the media in the justice system gives us a Milgaard case where 25 years too late, an innocent man is released from a false allegation, only by someone who writes and for good cause, undermines trust in the administration of justice when that administration is clearly wrong. But the clarity of the wrong is never clear at the beginning. For 25 years, the system said Truscott, Milgaard, Sophenow, Morin, and many others were guilty, when they really were not. Does the Chief Justice think these injustices only occur in first degree murder cases? Should there always be public trust in the administration of justice? What if the courts are wrong? Why shouldn’t the media point this out? Why should the judiciary be above criticism? I say the media need to criticize the administration of justice.
So why does the Chief Justice require media trust building? Because she is now the authority. Authority always demands protection for itself and it has the means to achieve it.
Chief Justice McLachlin also wondered whether fairness and accuracy might be lost in the world of Facebook, tweets, and instant messaging.
One might equally wonder whether people in conversation are fair and accurate, but should it matter? Where should regulation stop? Don’t we want people to discuss the justice system in their own words, or should they just agree? Should the justice system co-opt and regulate the media of modern discussion: the internet.
As one who is frequently misquoted, misrepresented, and vilified in the media, I would say the media are already unfair and inaccurate. She only has a different view because given her position of power and prestige; the media are always deferential, respectful, and solicitous. The mainstream media and the establishment go hand in hand. The mainstream media have the guile to slant the news to make the establishment look good if they know what’s good for them and they do.
Imagine the attitude of someone who says “Some bloggers will be professionals and academics providing thoughtful commentary and knowledge. Others will fall short of basic journalistic standards.” What a series of fallacies and false assumptions are inherent in these two statements. First, the fallacy of authority, as if academics and professionals are not biased and have no evil intent, but only objectively present analysis. Some do and some don’t. Academia and the professions are rife with political motives, intrigue, and self-serving cliques. I well remember the Milgaard case was seen as so exemplary it was in our evidence text in the late 1960s. Secondly, basic journalistic standards are a problematic assertion. What are they? My experience is that there aren’t any if you are unpopular, and if you are popular or powerful like the Chief Justice of Canada, you just have to mention those words and heads nod in agreement as they do to most of your statements.
Finally, how can “Twitter inform the public accurately or adequately in 140 characters or less the real gist of a complex constitutional decision?” Here to me we see a series of questionable assumptions. Firstly, what Supreme Court of Canada decision lately even hopes to inform the public, being usually in 140 paragraphs or pages, not characters? The various paragraphs, complex language, and conflicting dissents frequently leave lawyers in doubt. Older decisions of the court 60 years or more ago, before the era of cut and paste, were short, simple, and comprehensible, so where do long decisions lead us? To even longer commentary and confusion as well as an intellectually sterile, incomprehensible, technical language, which is better suited to occult societies than public understanding. The use of terms of art so typical of Supreme Court writing is specifically designed to exclude the public and build the professional monopoly of the elite. If the Supreme Court wants “real gist” (which seldom can be found) to be publicly understood, maybe they should write short, comprehensible, simple, and principled judgements rather than criticize much less ban Twitter.
It’s one thing for judges to decide to regulate their own behaviour, perhaps not musing in public, but it’s another for them to tell the public how they can communicate their observations and opinions about the justice system.
The regulation of online publicity is really impossible if you allow one person to communicate to another, because they will do so about the courts and justice as well. The hardest thing is to lose control of the messages, especially about yourself, as I have come to know from the selective, one-sided, seemingly uncorrectable Wikipedia biography of me. But any public figure knows the alternative is worse. To control what others say about you by force of law is impossible except for blatant false statements of fact, which seldom go unpunished. For the rest – fair comment – which usually isn’t fair, we have to grin and bear it. If we do, why should the courts be any better protected? Or does the Chief Justice really prefer an elite of professionals and academics to decide what we think?
Friday, January 20, 2012
On the Sinking of the Costa Concordia
The captain abandons his ship and claims he fell overboard. This is a metaphor for more than the Italian political scene. All current leadership in the Western World -- Britain, Europe, USA, Canada, Australia -- all are sleep walking to disaster with the same attitude as the Captain of the Costa Concordia who ordered dinner after the ship struck a rock over which he had driven his 3000 passengers, a rock which eviscerated his boat.
The political leaders of all major nations are driving by disastrous shallow waters in the Middle East, Afghanistan, Iraq, and beyond, to waive to the lobby in their domestic political scene. They preen and perform their ritual dances at elections, while enormous unfunded liabilities are increased and they build up burdens on people and powers of oppression in their governments. soon, they will strike a rock.
When they do, you can expect them, like the Italian captain, to blame their circumstances on others and leave no one in charge to handle the disaster they created. They will Schettino us all and scuttle the ship. The collapse of Rome was followed by almost 1,000 years of retrogressive disaster. For example, the bridge over the Danube the Romans had built and abandoned after 450 AD was not replaced until 1840.
The real progress of the last 500 years is in jeopardy from the world's shallow leadership, who dress like a captain but don't really know how to drive the boat or why.
The political leaders of all major nations are driving by disastrous shallow waters in the Middle East, Afghanistan, Iraq, and beyond, to waive to the lobby in their domestic political scene. They preen and perform their ritual dances at elections, while enormous unfunded liabilities are increased and they build up burdens on people and powers of oppression in their governments. soon, they will strike a rock.
When they do, you can expect them, like the Italian captain, to blame their circumstances on others and leave no one in charge to handle the disaster they created. They will Schettino us all and scuttle the ship. The collapse of Rome was followed by almost 1,000 years of retrogressive disaster. For example, the bridge over the Danube the Romans had built and abandoned after 450 AD was not replaced until 1840.
The real progress of the last 500 years is in jeopardy from the world's shallow leadership, who dress like a captain but don't really know how to drive the boat or why.
Thursday, January 19, 2012
Wikipedia’s Brave Stand
Wikipedia has done no favours for me. In fact, their reports on me are evidhttp://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gifently slanted to portray me in a negative way, but I agree with and admire their stand on SOPA and PIPA. The U.S. Congress and legislators around the world are always looking for some altruistic or moral excuse to control the flow of influence and knowledge.
It is vitally important that everyone becomes aware of the inherent danger of allowing any government regulator anywhere to control, regulate, and thus cripple the small independent sources of unofficial information on small websites around the world who can’t afford to fight. In essence, the Congress and Senate in total ignorance (I hope) are sounding more and more like the Communist Party of China. Media control, knowledge control, thought control… stop it now or regret it later!
America has been the last best bastion of freedom. This fight is worth the effort. Congratulations to Wikipedia. I will write the State Department, or better still phone the consulate of the United States where I live.
It is vitally important that everyone becomes aware of the inherent danger of allowing any government regulator anywhere to control, regulate, and thus cripple the small independent sources of unofficial information on small websites around the world who can’t afford to fight. In essence, the Congress and Senate in total ignorance (I hope) are sounding more and more like the Communist Party of China. Media control, knowledge control, thought control… stop it now or regret it later!
America has been the last best bastion of freedom. This fight is worth the effort. Congratulations to Wikipedia. I will write the State Department, or better still phone the consulate of the United States where I live.
Thursday, January 12, 2012
Equal Rights for All!

The above article, which appeared in the Times Colonist on January 11, 2012, clearly demonstrates the great danger of special rights based on race. The inherrent capacity for convoluted interpretations of these special rights is indicitive of the confusion that will emerge when these rights are gradually expanded, as they appear to be. We as a country have disavowed the concept of discrimination on the basis of race, with the exception of course of all the special status accorded to those who consider themselves "First Nations." The concept of a nation state attributable to a small indiginous band is inherrently falacious and contradicts the importance of equality rights for all citizens. There cannot be a stable, sensible society with concepts of "Indiginous rights" which are distinct from those of the general population. It will, in the end, produce resentment and inequitable distribution of legal rights, which after all should be accorded without distinctions as to race.
It is part of the inherrent nature of Canada, inherited from the British Crown and its declarations of the ancient past (like the Royal Proclamation of 1764) in circumstances vastly different than present day circumstances that these special rights exist.
Western Canada, if independent, would not be a successor government of the government of Canada or of the Imperial Parliament of England. As such, we could define our legal and political rights in a distinct and fair manner. This is impossible under the present constitutional arrangement, as the Supreme Court of Canada has consistently upheld various versions of legal rights based on racial distinctions of supposedly indiginous origin. This is another reason why, unless independence is accomplished for Western Canada, the end result will be a demoralized, chaotic conflict between racial groups and rights based upon racial categories. This is quite the contrary to what everyone claims to espouse in the Canadian political system.
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
The Futility of Foreign Aid
Canada, I am told, gave $1-billion to Haiti for reconstruction, where I am also told that 500,000 are still homeless.
One wonders if there is actual effective assistance given for this money since so little is achieved, or if the systemic corruption which plagues Haiti is the cause. What value is there to sending money to a broken system like Haiti or Afghanistan?
One wonders if there is actual effective assistance given for this money since so little is achieved, or if the systemic corruption which plagues Haiti is the cause. What value is there to sending money to a broken system like Haiti or Afghanistan?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

